(Also available in Pyret)
Students are introduced to the Design Recipe as a scaffold for breaking down word problems into smaller steps. They apply the Design Recipe to fixing a file that launches a rocket!
Lesson Goals |
Students will be able to:
|
Student-Facing Lesson Goals |
|
Materials |
|
Supplemental Resources |
|
Key Points for the Facilitator |
|
- comments
-
messages in the code, generally ignored by the computer, to help people interacting with the code understand what it is doing
- data type
-
a way of classifying values, such as: Number, String, Image, Boolean, or any user-defined data structure
- domain
-
the type or set of inputs that a function expects
- example
-
shows the use of a function on specific inputs and the computation the function should perform on those inputs
- function definition
-
code that names a function, lists its variables, and states the expression to compute when the function is used
- purpose statement
-
a concise, detailed description of what a function does with its inputs
- range
-
the type or set of outputs that a function produces
- variable
-
a name or symbol that stands for some value or expression, often a value or expression that changes
🔗The Design Recipe 10 minutes
Overview
In this lesson students build on what they already know about multiple representations of functions (contracts, examples and definitions) to write purpose statements and gain fluency with the Design Recipe.
Launch
A word problem is a description of a situation, but seeing the math behind the words can be challenging!
In this lesson, students are going to learn a strategy for breaking down word problems, called the Design Recipe. They have actually seen most of the steps of the Design Recipe, but they haven’t seen how to put them together. There’s also one part of the Design Recipe that they haven’t seen yet: writing a purpose statement.
On its own, a contract is not enough information to generate examples and write a function definition. For example, the contract for circle says it needs a Number and two Strings, but that’s not the whole story! We can’t use negative numbers for the radius, we can only use "solid" or "outline" for the first String, and the last String has to be a color!
Contracts are great, but we need more detail! Programmers and Mathematicians alike find it helpful to restate a problem in their own words. After all, if you can’t explain a problem to someone else, you probably don’t understand it yourself!
-
On Matching Word Problems and Purpose Statements, we see four word problems and four purpose statements.
-
Take 2 minutes to read them and see if you can find any that describe the same thing and should be matched to each other.
-
What pairs did you come up with?
-
What do you Notice about those purpose statements? Do they have anything in common?
Purpose statements should have enough details to allow us to write examples without looking at the word problem!
-
Turn to Writing Examples from Purpose Statements, read the purpose statements, and write examples that satisfy each of the contracts and purpose statements.
-
For more practice, complete Writing Examples from Purpose Statements 2.
A good purpose statement must have three things:
-
A description of what the function consumes
-
A description of what the function produces
-
All the relevant information about how to produce that output
Investigate
Have students turn to Fixing Purpose Statements and identify (1) what important information got left out of each of the purpose statements, and (2) what unnecessary information got included!
-
What important information was missing from each purpose statement that you would need to solve the problem?
-
What extra information was included, that wasn’t needed to solve the problem?
Synthesize
What are the important elements of purpose statements? Why are purpose statements useful?
The Design Recipe in your Classroom The three steps of the Design Recipe are designed to mirror best practices that you may already be using in your classroom. It’s merely a collection of those practices, assembled in a structured way with great care taken to connecting each practice with the others. Writing the Contract and Purpose Statement is where students understand the word problem. If you have your students restate the problem in their own words, draw pictures, or underline the inputs and outputs in the word problem, you’re already using this practice! Writing examples and circling-and-labeling what changes is where students apply their understanding to concrete inputs. If you have your students work through some concrete examples before jumping straight to variables and formulas, and ask them "what’s the rule?" or "what’s the pattern?", you’re already using this practice!. Writing the definition is where students formalize and abstract this understanding to work with any input. This is where they identify the structure of the rule or pattern, independently of any specific inputs. The order of the recipe is a recommendation based on 20+ years of research about what works for most students, but that doesn’t mean this order works best for every student! Some may find it easier to work through a concrete example or two before thinking about Domain and Range, and there’s nothing wrong with that. We encourage you to use the Recipe in your classroom as often as possible, teaching students to be flexible with the tools and representations it includes. |
🔗Rocket Height! 25 minutes
Overview
Students are given a non-working program, which uses a linear function to determine the height of a rocket after a given length of time. The "broken" code is provided to lower cognitive load, allowing students to focus on comprehension (reading the code) and making use of structure (identifying where it’s broken).
Launch
There’s a lot of buzz out there around Artificial Intelligence (A.I.) tools, which claim to be able to solve math problems, write essays, and even write code for us! A few students found some A.I. that claims to be able to write Pyret programs for them. They asked the A.I. to generate code that makes a rocket blast off, starting on the ground (height=0) when the rocket first blasts off (time=0). The A.I. wrote the program for them - but are they ready to hand it in to their teacher? How do they know if it really solved the problem correctly?
-
Open the Rocket Height Starter File, and click "Run".
-
What happens when you press the space bar?
-
The seconds change, but the rocket doesn’t move!
-
-
What were you expecting to happen?
-
The rocket would move!
-
-
What happens when you press
b?-
The seconds go back down, but the rocket height stays at 0
-
-
Is
rocket-heightworking?-
No.
-
Direct students to close the window with the rocket, so that they can see the code.
If there are examples for how the program should work, we can automatically detect when AI writes bad code for us. But we didn’t get any warning here! Why not?
-
Type
(rocket-height 0)into the Interactions Area. -
As the program is currently written, what happens when we give the
rocket-heightfunction an input of 0?-
It returns 0.
-
-
Is that what we want it to do?
-
Yes!
-
-
As the program is currently written, what happens when we give the
rocket-heightfunction an input of 10?-
It returns 0.
-
-
Is that what we want it to do?
-
No!
-
-
Why did the examples pass?
-
The programmer only gave one example! We should always provide at least two examples. More complex functions will require us to think about what range of examples will be necessary to test that our function does what we want it to!
-
We should always test a function definition against at least 2 examples!
=== Investigate
Let’s use the Design Recipe to fix rocket-height, and get comfortable with writing purpose statements.
Complete Word Problem: rocket-height.
As students work, circle the room and make sure that their purpose statements are strong enough that they could write examples without looking at the original word problem. Encourage students to circle what’s changing in their examples and label with descriptive variables.
-
Once you’ve completed the Design Recipe page for
rocket-height, type the code into Definitions Area, replacing any missing and incorrect code with your own. -
When it’s working correctly, explore the other functions in the file.
For students needing more specific instructions about exploring the file, try the following:
-
Remove the comment from before the
(start rocket-height)and test the program. -
Put the comment back in front of
(start rocket-height), remove the comment from(graph rocket-height), and test the program. -
Try out
(space rocket-height) -
Try out
(everything rocket-height)
Teacher Tool: "Where’d You Get That?" This is a powerful tool that forces students to explain their thinking, making deeper connections between steps, and helps teachers guide students to find their own mistakes. It requires two people: the Challenger, and the Defender. Most of the time, the teacher is in the role of Challenger. The Challenger starts at the bottom of the page, physically pointing to one part of the Definition and asking "Where’d you get that?" The Defender has to physically point somewhere in the Examples, and explain what they’re pointing to supports their Definition. Next, the Challenger starts asking about the Examples and the Defender needs to show how their Contract and Purpose support them. This is repeated for every other step in the recipe, as students work their way back to the original word problem:
|
For teachers who cover quadratic and exponential functions, or have students who need more of a challenge, checkout the Rocket Height Challenges:
-
Changing slope: Can you make the rocket fly faster? Slower?
-
Changing sign: Can you make the rocket sink down instead of fly up?
-
Motivating Quadratic Functions: Can you make the rocket accelerate over time, so that it moves faster the longer it flies?
-
Practicing the Quadratic Formula: Can you make the rocket blast off and then land again?
-
More practice: Can you make the rocket blast off, reach a maximum height of exactly 1000 meters, and then land?
-
More practice: Can you make the rocket blast off, reach a maximum height of exactly 1000 meters, and then land after exactly 100 seconds?
-
Motivating Exponential Functions: Can you make the rocket fly to the edge of the the universe?
=== Synthesize
Even great programmers make mistakes sometimes. And in a world where AI is being used more and more, it’s critical that we be able to write examples so that we can detect when AI messes up!
-
What problems did you fix in AI’s code?
-
What did the other functions do?
-
Which step in the Design Recipe are you feeling the most confident about? The least? At this stage, it is normal for students to feel most confident about the Contract and Examples, and the least confident about Purpose Statements and Definitions.
Project Idea: Design Recipe Telephone Most computer programs are written by huge teams! It is critical that each team member records their thinking with enough detail for other team members to be able to pick up where they left off. In Design Recipe Telephone [rubric], students collaborate to complete a series of Design Recipe Problems, with each student being responsible for only one part of each problem in the set. You can use any word problems you like, but we have provided two sets that lend themselves particularly well to the activity. One set can be used to collaboratively update the functions in Collaboration Starter File - For use with Design Recipe Telephone Set 1, which generates a cool mystery image if all three problems are solved correctly! |
== Additional Exercises
For more practice connecting Examples and Contracts, have students complete Writing Examples from Purpose Statements 2.
While most problems in a math book ask students to solve something, the actual challenge is figuring out what the equation is that needs to be solved: setting it up is where the thinking happens, and solving it is just arithmentic. You can use the Design Recipe with any word problem where students need to figure out a functional relationship, and we’ve provided a Blank Design Recipe that you can use for any problem you like.
Optional: Ask students to create their own appropriately challenging word problem (with a solution) and collect the responses for later use as "Do Now" tasks or formative assessment.
To help you apply the Design Recipe to more of your scope and sequence, we’ve provided a library of Design Recipe worksheets which connect to various curricular goals. We hope that you will be inspired by this library, and begin using the Design Recipe with more of the problems in your book!
These materials were developed partly through support of the National Science Foundation,
(awards 1042210, 1535276, 1648684, and 1738598). 
Bootstrap by the Bootstrap Community is licensed under a Creative Commons 4.0 Unported License. This license does not grant permission to run training or professional development. Offering training or professional development with materials substantially derived from Bootstrap must be approved in writing by a Bootstrap Director. Permissions beyond the scope of this license, such as to run training, may be available by contacting contact@BootstrapWorld.org.